Monday, December 9, 2019
teachthought
  • Teaching
  • Learning
  • Critical Thinking
  • Literacy
  • Technology
  • More Topics
        • A-D

          • Admin
          • Apple
          • Apps
          • Assessment
          • Augmented & Virtual Reality
          • Blended Learning
          • Books
          • Brain-Based Learning Resources
          • BYOD
          • Critical Literacy
          • Curricula
          • Definitions
          • Digital Citizenship
        • D-G

          • Disruption & Innovation
          • ECE
          • Effective Learning Environments
          • English-Language Arts
          • Elementary School
          • English Second Language
          • Essential
          • Everything Else
          • Financial Literacy
          • Google Classroom
          • More Google Tools For The Classroom
          • Grant Wiggins
          • Growth Mindset
        • H-P

          • Hip-Hop
          • How-To
          • Ideas
          • Inquiry Learning
          • Inspirational!
          • Learning Models
          • Maker Education
          • Math
          • Middle & High School
          • Mobile Learning
          • Networking & Collaboration
          • New Teacher
          • Parents
        • P-W

          • Personalized Learning
          • Project-Based Learning
          • Questioning
          • Resources
          • Bloom’s Taxonomy
          • Social Media In The Classroom
          • STEM
          • Teaching & Learning Strategies
          • Student Engagement
          • Team-Building
          • Terry Heick
          • Tools
          • Whole Child
  • PD
        • Workshops

          • PBL Workshops
          • Inquiry Workshops
          • Growth Mindset Workshops
          • Differentiation Workshops
          • Assessment Workshops
          • Literacy Workshops
          • Leadership Workshops
          • More Workshops
        • More Info

          • Open Registration Workshops
          • Grow 20 Conference
          • School Partnerships
          • Request More Info
          • TeachThought Podcast
          • PD Newsletter
          • TeachThought PD FAQ
          • Read More
        • TeachThought PD Events

No Result
View All Result
Home Critical Thinking

20 Questions To Help Students Think Critically About News

by TeachThought Staff
November 25, 2019
in Critical Thinking
6 min read
3.3k
SHARES
9.6k
VIEWS
SharePinTweet

20 Questions To Help Students Think Critically About News

by TeachThought Staff

1. Who is saying what? That is, what author and publication are making what kind of claim about what topic or ideas?

2. Is what’s being said fact or opinion?

3. Does this headline seem true? (This is especially critical for ‘fact-based’ headlines.) If so, by whose standards? Who would disagree with it and why?

4. Is this headline entirely ‘true’/accurate or based instead on partially true information/data? Misleading information is often based on partial truths and then reframed to fit a particular purpose: cause an emotion such as fear, lead to a conversion of some kind such a social media share, purchase, signup, vote, etc.

5. Are there any embedded logical fallacies in the headline itself–especially emotional appeals or language intended to polarize readers and ‘click’?

6. Is the topic the headline is based on important? Worth understanding more deeply?

13 Digital Research Lessons For Google-First Students

Critical Reading: 50 Sentence Stems To Help Students Talk About What They Read

7. Who would this seem to benefit if accepted as ‘true’? Note, this doesn’t mean it’s ‘fake’ but understanding who benefits from changing perceptions is an important ‘fake news’ detecting tool.

8. Is this information, angle, or ‘take’ new or something that’s been said before (and either fact-checked or debunked)?

9. Is the data (fact-based) or position (opinion-based) inherent in the headline shared by other credible publishers or does it stand in contrast to the ‘status quo? If the latter, how does this affect the headline?

10 What background information would I need to be able to evaluate its credibility? Where can I get more information on the topics in the headline to better evaluate its credibility?

11. What do I stand to gain or lose if I accept this as true?

For the second set of questions to think critically about news headlines, we’re turning to the News Literacy Project, a media standards project that created a set of questions to help students think critically about news headlines.

12. Gauge your emotional reaction. Is it strong? Are you angry? Are you intensely hoping that the information turns out to be true or false?

13. Reflect on how you encountered this. Was it promoted on a website? Did it show up in a social media feed? Was it sent to you by someone you know?

14. Consider the headline or message:

a. Does it use excessive punctuation or ALL CAPS for emphasis?

b. Does it make a claim about containing a secret or telling you something that ‘the media’ doesn’t want you to know?

c. Don’t stop at the headline. Keep exploring!

15. Is this information designed for easy sharing, like a meme?

16. Consider the source of information:

a. Is it a well-known source?

b. Is there a byline (an author’s name) attached to this piece?

c. Go to the website’s ‘About’ section. Does the site describe itself as a ‘fantasy news’ or ‘satirical news’ site?

17. Does the example you’re evaluating have a date on it?

18. Does the example cite a variety of sources, including official and expert sources? Does the information this example provides appear in reports from (other) news outlets?

19. Does the example hyperlink to other quality sources?

20. Can you confirm, using a reverse image search, that any images in your example are authentic (i.e., haven’t been altered or taken from another context)?

21. If you searched for this example on a fact-checking site such as snopes.com, factcheck.org, or politifact.com, is there a fact-check that labels it as less than true?

Remember:

  • It is easy to clone an existing website and create fake tweets to fool people
  • Bots are extremely active on social media and are designed to dominate conversations and spread propaganda.
  • Fake news and other misinformation often use a real image from an unrelated event.
  • Debunk examples of misinformation whenever you see them. It’s good for democracy!

You can download the full ‘checkology’ pdf here and find more resources at checkology.org

Previous Post

An Interesting Game To Teach Students To Think Critically About Fake News

Next Post

How To Create A Forward-Leaning Curriculum

Related Posts

13 Digital Research Lessons For Google-First Students

13 Digital Research Lessons For Google-First Students

by TeachThought Staff
December 7, 2019
4
1.6k

When researching online, what's easiest to find may not necessarily be accurate or represent a full understanding.

Critical Reading: 50 Sentence Stems To Help Students Talk About What They Read

Critical Reading: 50 Sentence Stems To Help Students Talk About What They Read

by Terry Heick
October 29, 2019
0
19.1k

Critical reading is a matter of gathering knowledge, understanding context and seeing ideas from multiple perspectives to make sense of...




Trending

What Is Bloom’s Taxonomy? A Definition For Teachers

What Is Bloom’s Taxonomy? A Definition For Teachers

November 22, 2019
483.5k

20 Ways To Provide Effective Feedback For Learning

November 25, 2019
266.6k

100+ Bloom’s Taxonomy Verbs For Critical Thinking

December 6, 2019
201.3k

50 Ways To Use Bloom’s Taxonomy In The Classroom

November 3, 2019
145.2k
Load More




Grow

  • Podcast
  • Curricula
  • Newsletter
  • Books For Teachers
  • PD Events

PD

  • PBL
  • Technology
  • Assessment
  • Inquiry Learning
  • Differentiation
  • Request Info

More

  • About
  • Terms
  • Contact
  • Feedback
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy

Follow

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
No Result
View All Result
  • Critical Thinking
  • Teaching
  • Technology
  • Learning
  • Literacy
  • Podcast
  • Newsletter
  • Professional Development

Copyright © 2019 TeachThought, LLC | Kentucky | United States | Global