• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • Project-Based Learning
  • Critical Thinking
  • Teaching
  • Literacy
  • Learning Models
  • The Future Of Learning
The Importance Of Knowledge In Progressive Education

The Importance Of Knowledge In Progressive Education

November 29, 2018
18 Inconvenient Truths About Assessment

18 Inconvenient Truths About Assessment

February 22, 2019
I’m Not Sure What To Think About Backward Design

I’m Not Sure What To Think About Backward Design

February 21, 2019
The TeachThought Podcast Ep. 145 Project-Based Learning in the Math Classroom

The TeachThought Podcast Ep. 156 Building Community, Overcoming Barriers, Music Education

February 21, 2019
What Is The Identity Of Your Classroom?

What Is The Identity Of Your Classroom?

February 21, 2019
formative assessment

8 Of The Most Common Sources Of Formative Assessment Data

February 18, 2019
12 Priorities For The Modern Public School Teacher

12 Priorities For The Modern Public School Teacher

February 20, 2019
The TeachThought Podcast Ep. 145 Project-Based Learning in the Math Classroom

The TeachThought Podcast Ep. 155 Does Competition And School Choice Meaningfully Improve Education?

February 20, 2019
What Every Teacher Needs In Order To Grow

What Every Teacher Needs In Order To Grow

February 18, 2019
The TeachThought Podcast Ep. 145 Project-Based Learning in the Math Classroom

The TeachThought Podcast Ep. 154 Depolarizing America Through Inquiry And Critical Thinking

February 19, 2019
What Is eduCLIMBER? A Tool To Organize Student Data Once And For All

What Is eduCLIMBER? A Tool To Organize Student Data Once And For All

February 21, 2019
Think Like A Fitbit: Measuring What We Value

Think Like A Fitbit: Measuring What We Value

February 18, 2019
10 Ways To Be A More Reflective Teacher

10 Ways To Be A More Reflective Teacher

February 10, 2019
  • About
  • Contact Us
    • Report Issue
    • Advertise
  • Policies
    • Terms Of Use
    • Disclosure Page
    • Affiliate Disclosure
    • Cookie Policy
    • Privacy Policy
Friday, February 22, 2019
teachthought
  • Professional Development
    • TeachThought PD
    • Project-Based Learning
      • PBL Grow 19
    • Inquiry
    • Growth Mindset
    • Differentiation
    • Assessment
    • Literacy
    • Tech Integration
    • Maker Ed
    • Design Thinking
    • Leadership
  • Categories
    • Critical Thinking
    • Learning
    • Teaching
    • Technology
    • Future Of Learning
  • Resources
  • How-To
No Result
View All Result

The Importance Of Knowledge In Progressive Education

by Drew Perkins
November 29, 2018
in Education
0
52
SHARES
447
VIEWS
PinShareTweet

Read

Discuss: In Finland, teachers are not ‘inspected’

A Really Cool Database For Paper Airplanes

Report: ACT Scores Drop Again; Math Scores Hit 14-Year Low

The Importance Of Knowledge In Progressive Education

by Drew Perkins, Director of TeachThought Professional Development

I recently recorded a podcast that explored differing approaches to the role and importance of knowledge in teaching and learning.

In the podcast, the claim by Katharine Birbalsingh was that progressive education has foregone the teaching of knowledge to the great detriment of students. While I don’t deny that this may happen in some learning environments, it’s certainly not how I would describe quality progressive (or non-progressive for that matter) education. Instead what we hope to see and help grow in classrooms in which we work is an acquisition and use of necessary knowledge and understanding through a process of rich inquiry.

The idea that students need to acquire and even master knowledge before they should attempt to do things like apply, analyze, or synthesize, or even create strikes me as a not only traditional but limiting approach. While it can yield some benefits, it misses an opportunity to build other vital skills simultaneously and furthers the “playing school” narrative of compliance vs. commitment where we so often lose students interest and engagement.

If we’re viewing traditional vs. progressive teaching on a spectrum you might see the most traditional style on one end where the teacher is presenting the information or knowledge with the expectation that students will take it in, understand it, and be able to show they remember it on a test.

Moving along towards more progressive we might see teachers “front-loading” content (aka knowledge) before asking them to do some critical thinking with it. These are often called “projects” and at least there’s an attempt to engage students in critical thinking but not before they show they’ve come to some level of mastery of the things the teacher wants them to remember and understand.

If we were to follow the spectrum towards the “most progressive” we’d see much more radical approaches like unschooling or free school where a standard curriculum of knowledge can become elusive. Perhaps this is what Katharine Birbalsingh has in mind when she defines progressive education but this certainly isn’t the majority.

At TeachThought PD, our sweet spot for progressive teaching and learning sees teachers using rich inquiry to pull that knowledge and thinking from students by asking them to create from the onset. We believe there is real value and necessity for certain knowledge and want learners to learn it deeply by using it in multiple ways and for multiple reasons.

I’ve discussed this previously in Using Project-Based Learning To Flip Bloom’s Taxonomy For Deeper Learning but this process doesn’t minimize the role of knowledge. Instead, it places knowledge in an active role as learners identify and use what they need to know and learn in multiple ways to answer the Driving Question for a project. The goal here is to deepen the knowledge and understanding, not disregard it, all the while developing the skill of inquiry that we believe is vital for the modern world.

This type of teaching is difficult, but all teaching is difficult. Great progressive education requires teachers who are masterful at the design and architecture of a unit while also craftsmanlike in their employment of inquiry to know just how much and when to scaffold and support learning.

Providing all the knowledge and content as learning targets or “I Can” statements is kind of like watching a movie with the ending revealed on the wall next to the screen. Instead, let’s pull that knowledge and thinking from learners in a way that empowers them to transfer that process to other tasks and projects in their lives…school and non-school.

Sometimes I like to joke when working with schools that we’re not talking about “free range chicken” when we’re helping them grow their constructivist teaching chops. That’s to say that we aren’t in favor of classrooms where kids are just intellectually wandering about with no teacher directing the learning.

In fact, great constructivist learning emphasizes knowledge (and understanding) and we would push back on anything different.

Tags: PBLProject-Based Learning

Drew Perkins

TeachThought's Director of Professional Development, formerly with the Buck Institute for Education and the Collaborative for Teaching and Learning after 15 years of classroom teaching. Passionate about the leading of learning through inquiry, I have been called a professional thought stretcher due to my love for questioning.

Related Posts

Discuss: In Finland, teachers are not ‘inspected’

Discuss: In Finland, teachers are not ‘inspected’

by Terry Heick
November 29, 2018
0

Discuss: 'In Finland, teachers are not inspected' by Terry Heick Non-negotiable. Out of all of my experiences as a classroom...

A Really Cool Database For Paper Airplanes

A Really Cool Database For Paper Airplanes

by Terry Heick
October 26, 2018
0

A Really Cool Database For Paper Airplanes by Terry Heick When I was a kid, my dad taught me how...

Load More
Please Login to comment
  Subscribe  
Notify of




No Result
View All Result

Popular

  • A Visual Summary: 32 Learning Theories Every Teacher Should Know

    A Visual Summary: 32 Learning Theories Every Teacher Should Know

    34244 shares
    Share 34242 Tweet 0
  • What Is Bloom’s Taxonomy? A Definition For Teachers

    1511 shares
    Share 1511 Tweet 0
  • 10 Team-Building Games That Promote Critical Thinking

    401 shares
    Share 401 Tweet 0
  • 6 Types Of Assessment Of Learning

    594 shares
    Share 594 Tweet 0
  • 20 Ways To Provide Effective Feedback For Learning

    2323 shares
    Share 2323 Tweet 0
  • 21 Simple Ideas To Improve Student Motivation

    890 shares
    Share 890 Tweet 0




TeachThought

Copyright © 2019 TeachThought, LLC | Kentucky | United States | Global

TeachThought Publishing

  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Policies

Social Media

No Result
View All Result
  • Search
  • Critical Thinking
  • Teaching
  • Technology
  • Learning
  • The Future Of Learning
  • Literacy
  • Education
  • Podcast

Copyright © 2019 TeachThought, LLC | Kentucky | United States | Global

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Fill the forms bellow to register

*By registering into our website, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.
All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
wpDiscuz
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
You are going to send email to

Move Comment