• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • Project-Based Learning
  • Critical Thinking
  • Teaching
  • Literacy
  • Learning Models
  • The Future Of Learning
Helping Students Fail

Helping Students Fail: A Framework

December 10, 2017
18 Inconvenient Truths About Assessment

18 Inconvenient Truths About Assessment

February 22, 2019
I’m Not Sure What To Think About Backward Design

I’m Not Sure What To Think About Backward Design

February 21, 2019
The TeachThought Podcast Ep. 145 Project-Based Learning in the Math Classroom

The TeachThought Podcast Ep. 156 Building Community, Overcoming Barriers, Music Education

February 21, 2019
What Is The Identity Of Your Classroom?

What Is The Identity Of Your Classroom?

February 21, 2019
formative assessment

8 Of The Most Common Sources Of Formative Assessment Data

February 18, 2019
12 Priorities For The Modern Public School Teacher

12 Priorities For The Modern Public School Teacher

February 20, 2019
The TeachThought Podcast Ep. 145 Project-Based Learning in the Math Classroom

The TeachThought Podcast Ep. 155 Does Competition And School Choice Meaningfully Improve Education?

February 20, 2019
What Every Teacher Needs In Order To Grow

What Every Teacher Needs In Order To Grow

February 18, 2019
The TeachThought Podcast Ep. 145 Project-Based Learning in the Math Classroom

The TeachThought Podcast Ep. 154 Depolarizing America Through Inquiry And Critical Thinking

February 19, 2019
What Is eduCLIMBER? A Tool To Organize Student Data Once And For All

What Is eduCLIMBER? A Tool To Organize Student Data Once And For All

February 21, 2019
Think Like A Fitbit: Measuring What We Value

Think Like A Fitbit: Measuring What We Value

February 18, 2019
10 Ways To Be A More Reflective Teacher

10 Ways To Be A More Reflective Teacher

February 10, 2019
  • Podcast
  • Newsletter
Sunday, February 24, 2019
teachthought
  • Professional Development
    • TeachThought PD
    • Project-Based Learning
      • PBL Grow 19
    • Inquiry
    • Growth Mindset
    • Differentiation
    • Assessment
    • Literacy
    • Tech Integration
    • Maker Ed
    • Design Thinking
    • Leadership
  • Categories
    • Critical Thinking
    • Learning
    • Teaching
    • Technology
    • Future Of Learning
  • Tools & Resources
    • Definitions
    • How-To
    • Google Tools For The Classroom
    • Apple Tools For The Classroom
    • Resources
No Result
View All Result

Helping Students Fail: A Framework

by Terry Heick
December 10, 2017
in Teaching
15
410
SHARES
421
VIEWS
PinShareTweet

Read

18 Inconvenient Truths About Assessment

I’m Not Sure What To Think About Backward Design

What Is The Identity Of Your Classroom?

learning-to-fail-fiHelping Students Fail: A Framework

by Terry Heick

Ed note: This post has been updated from a previous publishing

As teachers, allowing students to see failure as a negative experience is one of the worst things we can do.

Granted, this isn’t unique to education. The idea of risk-taking, failing, looking, leaping, try-try-again is ingrained in our cultural DNA. But in education, we certainly have made it dramatic. In fact, we don’t even need the whole word anymore. Failure erodes to fail, which itself erodes to simply F.

Every bit of effort, every miscommunication, every missing skill or competency, every degree and layer of performance–academic and otherwise–is distilled down into a single character.

And there isn’t a mark lower than an “F”–a hundred zeroes and missing assignments still say F, which means there is literally doing nothing at all would’ve yielded the same letter. That’s pretty brutal. (On a related note, here are 12 alternatives to letter grades.)

What Does It Mean To “Fail”?

You can fail a test or course, but the idea of failing to understand has a completely different connotation. The former could be as much about missing work or organizational habits or even literacy levels; the latter, while subjective, is something else entirely.

If understanding is about making meaning, then failure is always only temporary. Making meaning is a present participle that indicates an ongoing process. It’s indefinite, if for not other reason than we can never fully and completely understand anything.

Constructivism as a learning theory makes room for failure at its very core, describing learning as an active process and continuous process, stratified in layers of performance. Creating, making, constructing, building, designing and other related terms reflect the nature of both learning and knowledge as a cycle.

Some kind of feedback loop is crucial, especially in academic settings where the pace of the course is set before we even know the students’ names. So it’s easy to excuse interrupting this cycle to assess understanding, which we do in various forms.

And provided we’re clear that even a perfect assessment is simply a snapshot that’s already dated by the time the feedback is given, there’s nothing wrong with that. Knowledge is both perishable and alive.

If we can use grades and feedback and gamification and other processes to communicate that to learners and parents and communities, then all is well. (Gamification, properly used, is capable of uncovering the nuance of the learning process.)

But so far, we’ve got room to improve here. Which is where the idea of “failing forward” comes in. Helping students fail isn’t just a matter of making them feel better–it’s about thinking like a scientist, farmer, designer, or CEO–failing gives me the data I need to proceed. And knowledge? Those letter grades don’t mean much. An A doesn’t guarantee understanding, and an F doesn’t preclude it.

To ‘fail’ could mean a thousand things. It’s also not that simple. Failure doesn’t give us much more than a starting point.

Which is exactly why students need help to understand it.

The Role Of Failure In Learning

Properly understood, failure can help students see learning as a personal journey rather than a matter of external performance. It emphasizes meaning as contextual, and distinguishes procedural knowledge from content knowledge.

The primary value, then, might be in teaching students learning and knowledge rather than responsibility.

learning-to-fail-fiHelping Students Fail: A Framework

Where can I start as a teacher?

By Clarifying The Meaning

The Idea: Distinguishing knowledge from process so students can see failure not as one thing, but a hundred. (Or fewer, depending on grade level and situation.)

Guiding questions: How can I help students separate knowledge from performance? Considering their goals–and the goals of education–is it viable for them to value both?

By Providing Context

The Idea: Understanding the scale, impact, and nature of failure. The “fail” extends this* far, for example–this lesson, this test, this class, this project, this community, this goal, and so on. The impact is this broad, and is or is not correctable.

You might specify (guess?) what caused the failure–or help them learn to do it themselves, then celebrate that specification as a kind of triumph. We found the problem!

Guiding questions: What is the nature of this failure for this student? And as a result, how should I respond, and how should they respond?

By Designing Transparent Processes

The Idea: Illuminating learning as a systematic process that learners and families actually understand

Guiding questions: How can I design learning so that the priorities, process, and terms of success are both transparent and collaboratively constructed with learners?

By Illuminating Progress

The Idea: Emphasizing iteration & progress over “finishing” & completion

Guiding questions: How can I emphasize iteration & progress over “finishing” and “completion”? How can I create always-on learning & growth? How can I design work that students are both willing and interested in returning to to improve?

adapted image attribution flickr user tactom; Helping Students Fail: A Framework

Tags: Experienced TeacherOur BestTerry Heick

Terry Heick

Founder & Director of TeachThought, humanist, technologist, futurist, failed philosopher, macro thinker extraordinaire.

Related Posts

18 Inconvenient Truths About Assessment

18 Inconvenient Truths About Assessment

by Terry Heick
February 22, 2019
35

18 Inconvenient Truths About Assessment by Terry Heick For in-person professional development from TeachThought on effective assessment (or any other...

I’m Not Sure What To Think About Backward Design

I’m Not Sure What To Think About Backward Design

by Terry Heick
February 21, 2019
0

image attribution flickr user the wonderful 'woodleywonderworks' I’m Not Sure What To Think About Backward Design...

Load More
Please Login to comment
4 Comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
sydney willcox

Model is right, the language needs a tweek. Things happen in more than one place. I also have created this framework aligning Piaget to standards based grading. This is a Piaget Pie of assessment so kids & I can see where they are in their place of learning. I now layout their assignments on drawing boards with all 4 aspects visible at a glance. I can immediately see where they are and which piece is causing their struggle. When I collected first assignments yesterday, I could point to where they were, why they were and strategies they could consider moving… Read more »

Vote Up0Vote Down 
4 years ago
| View Replies (2)
Kevin

Great article. Sydney – I would love to see that file also. Thank you. kevin dot conforti dot 1 at gmail dot com.

Vote Up0Vote Down 
4 years ago




No Result
View All Result

Popular

  • A Visual Summary: 32 Learning Theories Every Teacher Should Know

    A Visual Summary: 32 Learning Theories Every Teacher Should Know

    34899 shares
    Share 34897 Tweet 0
  • What Is Bloom’s Taxonomy? A Definition For Teachers

    1515 shares
    Share 1515 Tweet 0
  • 10 Team-Building Games That Promote Critical Thinking

    407 shares
    Share 407 Tweet 0
  • 6 Types Of Assessment Of Learning

    596 shares
    Share 596 Tweet 0
  • 20 Ways To Provide Effective Feedback For Learning

    2337 shares
    Share 2337 Tweet 0
  • 21 Simple Ideas To Improve Student Motivation

    891 shares
    Share 891 Tweet 0




TeachThought

Copyright © 2019 TeachThought, LLC | Kentucky | United States | Global

TeachThought Publishing

  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Policies

Social Media

No Result
View All Result
  • Search
  • Critical Thinking
  • Teaching
  • Technology
  • Learning
  • The Future Of Learning
  • Literacy
  • Education
  • Podcast

Copyright © 2019 TeachThought, LLC | Kentucky | United States | Global

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Fill the forms bellow to register

*By registering into our website, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.
All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
wpDiscuz
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
You are going to send email to

Move Comment